16 Handles
  • Photos
  • Menu
  • Location
  • Work Hours
  • Business info
  • Reviews

16 Handles Menu

Menu 16 Handles-1
Menu 16 Handles-1
Menu 16 Handles-2
Menu 16 Handles-2

Soft Serve

Birthday Cake Frozen Yogurt
$6.95
Our fro-yo take on a classic cake batter ice cream
Chocolicious Frozen Yogurt
$6.95
Classic and creamy chocolate frozen yogurt made with real cocoa
Classic Vanilla Frozen Yogurt
$6.95
Classic vanilla soft serve fro-yo
Cookie Dough Ice Cream
$6.95
Cookie Dough Ice Cream is the perfect indulgence. We fold real cookies and chocolate chips into 16 Handles' all natural, soft serve ice cream. Treat yo'self!
Cookies & Cream Frozen Yogurt
$6.95
The name says it allthis frozen yogurt flavor is a dessert lover's dream!
Cotton Candy Frozen Yogurt
$6.95
This carnival favorite has a sweet, airy taste that will make your inner child scream with glee
Original Tart Frozen Yogurt
$6.95
Tart and fresh fro-yo with a classic yogurt taste that balances tart and sweet flavors
Oat Milk Vanilla Soft Serve (V)
$6.95
Our flavorologist wanted to make a oat milk vanilla that was so good you wouldnt even know it's not dairy. This bold new vanilla is creamy and delicious, and sure to satisfy your dessert craving!
Peanut Butter Perfection Frozen Yogurt
$6.95
Calling all peanut butter lovers! Our smooth and creamy Peanut Butter Perfection is made with natural, roasted peanut butter
Pomegranate Raspberry Sorbet (V)
$6.95
This classic superfruit sorbet has been on our menu since opening day!
Salted Caramel Frozen Yogurt
$6.95
One of our most popular flavors everthe perfect sweet & salty dessert
Oat Milk Chocolate Cherry Soft Serve (V)
$6.95
When you think about chocolate cherry cordials, do you imagine a thick chocolate shell with a sweet juicy red cherry bursting out? Well that's what we imagined when we crafted this new, creamy artisan oat milk vegan flavor!
Watermelon Sorbet (V)
$6.95
Juicy, sweet, and summery watermelon sorbet. It's like a frozen picnic for your taste buds
Zero Sugar Added NY Cheesecake Frozen Yogurt
$6.95
All the iconic flavor of a slice of homemade New York cheesecake swirled into our fro-yo, this time with a no sugar added recipe!

Milkshakes

Vanilla Milkshake
$8.95
Made with premium vanilla syrup
Chocolate Milkshake
$8.95
Made with Ghirardelli chocolate sauce
Cookies & Cream Milkshake
$8.95
Made with crushed Oreos

Edible Cookie Dough by DO

Cake Batter Cookie Dough
$12.50
Cake batter, white chocolate and milk chocolate chips with sprinkles. 8 oz. container. Made by DO, Cookie Dough Confections.
Brookie Dough
$12.50
Signature chocolate chip + brownie batter, swirled together. 8 oz. container. Made by DO, Cookie Dough Confections.
Sugar Cookie Dough
$12.50
Sugar cookie dough topped with sugar sprinkles. 8 oz. container. Made by DO, Cookie Dough Confections.

Bottled Beverages

Water Bottle (16.9 oz)
$1.75
Please note: brand my vary by location
Can of Diet Coke
$1.95
Can of Diet Coke

If you're craving a sweet indulgence, 16 Handles offers a delightful menu packed with a variety of treats that will satisfy your dessert cravings in no time. Their signature Soft Serve collection is nothing short of magical, starting with the fun and festive Birthday Cake Frozen Yogurt—a creamy, cake-flavored frozen yogurt that brings the joy of a birthday party to every bite. For chocolate lovers, the Chocolicious Frozen Yogurt offers a rich, velvety chocolate experience, while the classic Vanilla Frozen Yogurt provides a smooth and timeless taste. If you're in the mood for something a bit more decadent, the Cookie Dough Ice Cream and Cookies & Cream Frozen Yogurt are irresistible options, each offering a unique twist on beloved dessert flavors.

For a thicker, more indulgent treat, their Milkshakes are the way to go. Whether you prefer the creamy simplicity of a Vanilla Milkshake, the rich flavor of a Chocolate Milkshake, or the crunchy delight of a Cookies & Cream Milkshake, each shake is perfectly blended to create a mouthwatering experience.

If you’re in the mood for something to snack on while sipping your shake, 16 Handles also offers Edible Cookie Dough from DO, a real treat for any cookie lover. Try the Cake Batter Cookie Dough for a playful, smooth taste, the Brookie Dough for a decadent blend of chocolate chip and brownie dough, or the classic Sugar Cookie Dough for a simple yet delicious bite.

To wash it all down, choose from a selection of Bottled Beverages, including a refreshing Water Bottle (16.9 oz) or a classic Can of Diet Coke to keep things light.

With a diverse and exciting menu like this, 16 Handles ensures there’s something for everyone to enjoy.

16 Handles

16 Handles in Lynbrook, NY offers a wide range of frozen yogurt, milkshakes, and edible cookie dough options. With dairy-free and vegan choices, along with a variety of toppings, this self-serve froyo spot is a favorite among customers. Clean, sanitary, and with helpful staff, it's a must-visit for yogurt lovers. Contact them at (516) 341-7242 for delivery or takeout.

Follow Us
  • Yelp
Copyright 2025 All rights reserved.